Customer Feeback

Mister Pizza Elmwood

With many pizzerias to choose from in Buffalo, NY, Mister Pizza Elmwood sets itself apart from the rest by using only the freshest ingredients in all of the products we offer. Read what some of our satisfied customers had to say...

"They did it again! :D"

Mister Pizza on Elmwood Ave. in the city blows me away every time with their amazing customer service. I am not an easy customer to deal with since I have strong allergies to many foods and make many special requests. They always get it right and go above and beyond to ensure my complete satisfaction. Kevin, a manager and the entire team there is always polite. My food always tastes great and if they make a mistake, all you have to do is say something and they fix it with pleasure. I'm not sure why others say they're having issues. I've been eating delivered food from this location for YEARS and have always been delighted by my experience and I feel I get my money's worth and then some. Thanks, Guys! <3

04/26/2013
Posted by Christina Van Gale

"Quality Food"

Friendly staff. Great management. Quality food. Plus, vegan and gluten free options. Does it get better than this? Yes! Because, I've been in there and I've seen how this business positively affects our community. Order from Mister Pizza and taste and see for yourself!

04/10/2013
Posted by C.V.

"Friendly and Quick"

My girlfriend and I love the mini pack. The Mr Veggie Pizza with honey crust & BBQ Cajun wings is our favorite. Delivery guys and service behind the counter are friendly and quick. Great representation of Buffalo Pizza.

02/28/2013
Posted by Austin J.

"Consistently Good"

Always a good pie at Mister Pizza. In a town with lots of great Pizza, this is always one of the best.

09/09/2007
Posted by lovinbuffalo

"Terrific Pizza"

While they are pricey the pizza makes up for it, best pizza in Buffalo in my opinion whether you get a full pizza or just slices, it is wonderful.

06/14/2007
Posted by bugmenot21856

"Great Pizza Delivery"

The pizza is awesome!!! More expensive than other smaller pie places, but always wonderful and worth your dollars if you have enough. Better service and cheaper that the other 2 large pizza shops in Buffalo.

01/15/2007
Posted by rwalley211

"Great Pizza, Fast Delivery"

Ever since I can remember, my family was always a Mister Pizza family (we never really got into the whole LaNova's thing). Great pizza, fast delivery, even faster if you go pick it up (it's ready about 10 minutes after you get off the phone). Their wings are great too...which is saying a lot because you can find some damn good wings in Buffalo. And a huge upgrade when they moved from deep in the West Side over to Elmwood.

12/15/2006
Posted by Becka D.

"Great Service, Better Food"

The great service at MISTER PIZZA is only surpassed by the great food. Pizza's are incredible, wings are very good. BBQ pit wings are the best in town. There are tons of pizzas to choose from, one is better than the next.

07/12/2005
Posted by ub123

"Yummm"

The best Pizza ever. Best in Buffalo, Chicago, NC, NYC, Best Pizza period. Great Chicken finger pizza, steak pizza, all are great. You pay a little more, but the quality is the best. Have had the chicken fingers and boneless wings, chicken wings, and several other items. All very good. Subs are average, Pizza is GREAT.

12/30/2004
Posted by smj429

"Best Food"

I spent 35 out of my 41 yrs in buffalo and visted a few months ago no ones pizza is close to being as good. I live in north carolina now nothing compares. I only have positive things to say about mister pizza, I drive the 900 miles sometimes just to get a good pizza pie and visit.

08/14/2004
Posted by dcoch

"Great Selection"

Mister Pizza has a great selection of pizza. My favorite is the BBQ chicken pizza. Their crust can get a bit crunchy though. Otherwise it is very good pizza.

11/27/2002
Posted by kaycigee


Vegetarian Item = Vegetarian item
Delivery Charge & Sales Tax Not Included. Prices Effective December 15, 2016.
Subject to Change Without Notice. All photos are actual Mister Pizza products, shot on-site at Mister Pizza Elmwood.

Mister Pizza will only recognize menus on our website or menus handed out at our location and deemed to be current.
We will not honor menu pricing posted on other websites or establishments.