" 7 Days Without Pizza Makes One Weak! "™ Buffalo, NY Pizzeria • Elmwood Ave.   »   Mister Pizza Elmwood

A Buffalo Legend in Pizza

7 Days Without Pizza Makes One Weak!™

Best Pizza in Buffalo!

Whether you want a classic cheese & pepperoni pizza, or one of our many Specialty Pizzas, Mister Pizza Elmwood has you covered.

Over 40 Varieties!

If it's not on the menu, you can create your own pizza to your liking. Try any of our pizzas with New York style thin crust or Chicago Style thick crust at no extra charge.

Wings & Fingers

We take great pride in knowing that we serve our customers in the Buffalo, New York area the Best Chicken Wings in Town!

Subs & Hoagies

All subs are served on Fresh White or Wheat Seedless Rolls or our new Tomato Basil Rolls with Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes and your choice of Oil, Mayo or Miracle Whip.

Tacos & Wraps

All Tacos are served on a Soft Shell with Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and your choice of Sauce. Mild, Medium, Hot or Suicidal.

Dinners & Salads

All salads are prepared fresh and made to order. Available with your choice of Italian, Lo-Cal Italian, French, Ranch, Greek, Honey Mustard or Bleu Cheese Dressing.

Sides & Extras

All menu items are made with the highest quality ingredients so as to maintain Mister Pizza's outstanding record of customer satisfaction.

New Catering Menu!

All of our dishes are made from scratch using only the freshest possible ingredients including seasonal produce and high-quality meats.

Mister Pizza Elmwood

Featuring an outside patio to enjoy our delicious food over-looking Elmwood Avenue. We can also accommodate delivery orders directly to your home or business 7 days a week.

Buffalo's Best Pizza, We Are Number One!

During the 20th century, pizza went from a snack to a staple of the American diet. Now that the 21st has arrived, Mister Pizza is dedicated to combining wholesome ingredients like vegetables, meats and cheeses with an old authentic Italian recipe.

As customers' tastes have changed, Mister Pizza has expanded its menu to include not only a wide variety of specialty pizzas, but also a large selection of chicken wings, salads and subs. All menu items are made with the highest quality ingredients so as to maintain Mister Pizza's outstanding record of customer satisfaction.

News & Updates